April 16, 2012

Optimizing the Braves’ Lineup

The following are a couple of optimal lineups for the Braves, based on 2012 preseason projections from ZiPS (found here: http://www.baseballthinkfactory.org/oracle/discussion/2012_zips_projections_-_atlanta_braves).

A nice summary of lineup optimization, from “The Book” by Tom Tango, Mitchell Lichtman and Andy Dolphin can be found here: http://www.beyondtheboxscore.com/2009/3/17/795946/optimizing-your-lineup-by

With Chipper:

Heyward

Chipper

Uggla

McCann

Freeman

Bourn

Prado

Pastornicky

Without Chipper:

Prado

Heyward

Uggla

McCann

Freeman

Bourn

Francisco/Diaz

Pastornicky

There are two notable differences between the optimal lineups and the lineups the Braves will likely employ this season.  Michael Bourn is hitting sixth in my optimal lineups.  Dan Uggla is hitting third.

Traditionally managers have made sure to put their best fast hitter in the leadoff spot.  Speed is nice, but it’s much more important for the leadoff man to get on base.  Think about it, the leadoff man is naturally going to hit in front of the very best hitters and hitters with power.  Those types of hitters will advance runners rather easily.  There is no need to rely greatly on speed.  A leadoff hitter is going to score on a homerun no matter how fast he is.

Speed is better utilized in front of high-contact, singles hitters.  These hitters usually hit lower in the lineup.  Juan Francisco really doesn’t fit this description but Prado and Diaz fit it perhaps better than any hitters on the team, although Prado has some pop.  But basically it’s somewhat counterproductive to have Bourn’s speed at the top of the order where a runner with just decent speed can advance two or three bases on an extra-base hit from Chipper, Uggla, McCann or Freeman.

Please note I’m not saying Bourn is an awful choice for the leadoff spot.  Bourn is a decent on-base guy and therefore is fine in the leadoff spot.  But this is about lineup optimization.

The other big change I would like to see is Dan Uggla hitting third instead of Freddie Freeman, Chipper Jones, Brian McCann or Jason Heyward.  The number three hitter should have some homerun power but, contrary to convention, the best hitter should not bat third.  The third hitter will typically come up with fewer runners on base than fourth and fifth place hitters.  The best hitters should bat leadoff, second and fourth, with the best power bats hitting lower.

I admit, there is something to be said for keeping players in spots where they are comfortable.  For example, maybe Bourn would see it as a slight if he were moved to the sixth spot.  And frankly the difference a decent lineup would make, in terms of runs scoring, over an optimal lineup isn’t that great, according to most batting-order studies.  Also, why cause the distraction?  If the Braves front office or Fredi Gonzalez decided (or any manager, for that matter) decided to go with a less traditional but more optimal order, it could cause a distraction.  The media and fan base might constantly ask the managers, the players, the GM what they think they are doing.  Again, frankly, it may not be worth the hassle the team would get from the media and fans who haven’t read in-depth studies on batting order optimization.

Twitter: @PayneBall

 

 

19 Responses to “Optimizing the Braves’ Lineup”

  1. 1
    Walker Says:

    Heaven forbid we take advantage of any way to make the team better. Hopefully baseball will sooner or later be able to shed misinformation and these old ideologies.

  2. 2
    Shaun Says:

    Thanks for reading, Walker.

    I think it is going to take the entire leadership of the organization buys in, from the GM and front office to the field manager and coaches, because I think the players will have to be educated and buy in.

    Players will have to gain the understanding that if you are batting sixth, it’s not as if it’s a huge slight to your skills. It just means you have speed and it’s better served lower in the order. If you are batting second, it doesn’t necessarily mean you have to bunt and hit to the right side and give yourself up.

    Seems to me it’s going to take leadership within an organization with the communication and teaching skills to lay these things all out to everyone in the organization, including the players.

    It seems that sabermetrics (or whatever you want to call it) has pretty much infiltrated most front offices and even most scouting departments. But I’m not sure how much and how many organizations try to educate players on those principles. Maybe they do more than we realize.

  3. 3
    Ham Says:

    Shaun, awesome stuff. Thanks!

  4. 4
    chromometer Says:

    Hi there, I discovered your blog via Google while looking for a related topic, your website came up, it seems great.
    I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
    Hi there, simply become alert to your blog via Google,
    and found that it’s truly informative. I’m gonna be careful for brussels.

    I will appreciate if you proceed this in future.
    Lots of other folks will likely be benefited out of your writing.
    Cheers!

  5. 5
    stained glass Says:

    A motivating discussion is definitely worth comment. I believe that you need to write
    more on this issue, it may not be a taboo subject but usually
    people do not speak about these topics. To the next!
    Best wishes!!

  6. 6
    www.rivervalleyconcrete.ca Says:

    Hi exceptional blog! Does running a blog similar to this take a
    great deal of work? I’ve very little expertise in coding however I had been hoping to start my own blog soon.
    Anyway, if you have any recommendations or tips for new blog owners please share.
    I understand this is off topic nevertheless I just wanted
    to ask. Appreciate it!

  7. 7
    saints row the third cheats Says:

    Humorous, it unfortunately does not range from the power to get sketches from your
    favorite musicians.
    Itis believed that by 2015, the social gambling business will soon be internationally worth
    $9 million.

  8. 8
    fatmanna.com Says:

    Imagination – Farming can be an exciting compositional device.
    The main anxieties are solving form and the typical dimensions correctly.

    You need to use crayons to incorporate realistic colors.

  9. 9
    www.mobileworld124.com Says:

    Thatis why it is crucial to understand how
    to get free farmville cash. Silence is obviously a lot better than something spoken. To read more about building your
    industry, go to farmville Accessories.

  10. 10
    best iphone apps 2013 games Says:

    Just in case, record s get deleted they can be
    got by you in the Back up files.

  11. 11
    download redsn0w Says:

    I don’t understand this article… You should check http://www.redsn0w.us/ for more details

  12. 12
    redsn0w Says:

    I don’t understand this article… You should check http://www.redsn0w.us/ for more details

  13. 13
    togetherwesave.blogspot.nl Says:

    They are commonly very easy: kill him steal this, or communicate with him him.

    Machine guns don’t work in Scribblenauts,
    although there are lots of ways to cut a tree
    down.

  14. 14
    download ifaith 6 Says:

    You will find how-to use ultrasn0w 1.2.3 below.
    Excellent betting price on a driver using a lot of expertise
    as well as a battle crew that is great. The applying type must be dually filled-up by the client.

  15. 15
    Renato Says:

    Also the tools included a level of ‘pointless’ for the operation. Then you
    will cherish Things of Battle 2 if you are a military
    gamer. Heritage has established this repeatedly again.

  16. 16
    download western front armies Says:

    Helpful info. Fortunate me I discovered your site unintentionally,
    and I am surprised why this twist of fate didn’t took place in advance!
    I bookmarked it.

  17. 17
    http://musicaatodoritmo12.blogspot.com/2012/06/shake-it-up-todos-los-bailes.html Says:

    Chiar a merge la plaja poate fi destul de o luptă .
    Din acest amestec al lui Procust , muzeul poate – dar nu ar trebui să fie obligate să –
    dobândi noi stoc . Crede-mă , o să vă mulțumesc
    pentru asta odată ce ești , că de mult pot garanta !

  18. 18
    Bonita Says:

    Hi there, You’ve done ann incredible job. I wikl definitely digg it and personally suggest to my friends.
    I amm sute they’ll be benefited from thios website.

    Allso visit my webpage … brissianoboutiques.info (Bonita)

  19. 19
    Free Law Of Attraction Says:

    The fact that this item provides useful, easy-to-implement
    ideas and strategies could be the greatest advantage of it all.
    I guess that lots of law of attraction goods fail due to the fact that they consist of practically nothing but fluffy, theoretical, impractical BS while the creator of Manifestation Miracle managed to place together a course that is laser targeted on having success, Fast!

    So when I first uncovered this program I was really
    pleased, even when it sounded a little too fantastic to be real, and decided to get a
    review copy right away. And it was the best choice! I believe that is the program which has aided me the most in understanding the
    law of attraction the most effective and to be capable to
    place it to excellent use, so I really am grateful for the
    creator for placing it together.

Leave a Reply