May 10, 2012

The Intentional HBP: Old School or Clown College?

Fredi Gonzalez earned his first ejection of the season during the Monday night series opener against the Cubs. After Eric O’Flaherty pegged DeJesus, the home plate umpire warned both clubs. Fredi came onto the field to ask for an explanation and got tossed. (Anytime a manager is ejected, it brings a smile to my face, no doubt the result of so many Bobby Cox memories.)

Fredi insists that O’Flaherty wasn’t trying to hit the batter, and I want to agree with him, but the pitch that hit DeJesus was the third pitch in a row to go way inside the strike zone. Because I don’t want to pony up the extra dough for MLB TV Premium, I was stuck listening to the home team broadcast. The Cubs commentators (Len Kasper and Bob Brenly) saw it as an obvious intentional HBP, payback for payback for an 0-2 breaking ball that slipped out of Tommy Hanson’s grip in the early innings. If it was intentional, it was foolish, because it resulted in a big run for the Cubbies.

As all this transpired, the commentators discussed Cole Hamels’s recent foray into the exciting business of intentional bean balls. His deliberate throwing at young phenom Bryce Harper earned Hamels a five-game suspension. Hamels openly admitted to throwing at Harper as a way of welcoming the cocky rookie into the big leagues.

I have so many problems with this that I don’t know where to begin. The Cubs broadcasters called Hamels stupid, but only for opening his mouth and admitting to his actions, not for throwing at Harper. Have intentional HBPs really become an accepted, expected part of the game? I find that a disgrace.

If you don’t think any harm is done by purposefully hitting a batter, take a trip to your local batting cages. Go to the cage with the fast-pitch machine, then stand on the plate, and turn into the pitch. And later, when you’re icing your back, remember that there is no way the pitching machine throws as hard as major leaguer.

Intentionally throwing at batters is dangerous, comes with a high potential for injury, and often results in retaliation from the opposing team. And if that’s not bad enough, it doesn’t make the sport of baseball look tough, or cool, but childish. It makes juvenile punks out of professional athletes (and I know a thing or two about juvenile punks, because I used to be one). There’s no place in the game for this kind of strong-arm tactic. I think it’s time America’s pastime grew up.

Of course, Hamels received his comeuppance. Better than the five-game suspension, he has to deal with the embarrassment of being the first MLB pitcher to allow a teenager to steal home in more than fifty years. Almost as bad as accusing Chipper of relaying signs from second base, but I’ll save that can of worms for another day.

I’d be glad to hear some other perspectives on the intentional HBP. Leave your thoughts in the comments or send a tweet my way: @ThomasMDuncan.



7 Responses to “The Intentional HBP: Old School or Clown College?”

  1. 1
    Walker Says:

    Completely agree.

    Grown men solving problems by throwing baseballs at each other. HA!

  2. 2
    BluesMan Says:

    Agree as well…enjoyed the blog!

  3. 3
    Brendt Wayne Waters Says:

    If Harper had hit a no-doubter off Hamels and admired it in some Bonds-esque masturbatory way, then *maybe* the kid might have it coming in his next AB. But simply being good and young is no reason to get plunked.

  4. 4
    eric Says:

    I flipped some guy the bird after he cut me off on 285 today. Old school.

  5. 5
    Mike Says:

    Thanks for the comments, guys.

    3 – If I were the pitcher, and Harper did that to me, I would want to strike him out in the next AB, make him look silly, but that’s just my opinion.

    4 – Yep. You can Hamels should hang out sometime.

  6. 6
    saccharomyces boulardii probiotic Says:

    If your physician is not familiar with the clinical references then the merit of any critical assessment should be considered.
    Anaerobic exercises uses energy sources that are stored
    in the muscles and is not dependent on oxygen. Exercise and diet are
    the two most popular means of losing weight.

  7. 7
    Allan Says:

    Kidney disease will take several years to travel from chronic kidney
    disease (CKD) to kidney failure. Caldwell Esselstyn, from the
    Cleveland Heart Clinic, began his very own research.
    The key the following is, keep the water level
    the best temperature, with the best salt balance (yes, salt is required
    in a freshwater tank), as well as your fish will
    thrive, and live long, healthy lives.

Leave a Reply